Gold Investing 101: Comparing Options

physical-vs-digital-vs-derivatives-vs-gold-publicly-listed-companies-879x489

Gold has long been a cornerstone of investment portfolios, offering a hedge against inflation, currency devaluation, and economic uncertainty. Its unique properties—such as a resistance to corrosion and universal acceptance— has solidified its status as a reliable store of value. For Malaysian investors, understanding the various avenues for gold investment is crucial in order to make informed decisions that align with your financial goals. From physical gold to digital equivalents, derivatives, and public-listed gold companies, each option has its benefits and drawbacks.

Physical Gold: Definition and Examples

Investing in physical gold involves acquiring the metal in tangible forms such as jewellery, coins, and bullion.

Jewellery: Gold is crafted into wearable adornments such as rings, necklaces, and bracelets. The value of such pieces is influenced by gold purity, and can include alloys to enhance durability.
Coins: Struck by governments and private mints, gold coins are prized for their gold content and collectible value. Examples include the South African Krugerrand, the U.S. American Eagle, and the Canadian Maple Leaf.
Bullion: This refers to gold bars and ingots that are valued primarily by their weight and purity. Common forms include one-ounce bars and the larger 400-ounce bars held by central banks.

Benefits

Tangibility: Physical gold is a tangible asset that provides investors with a sense of security and control.
Intrinsic Value: Gold has maintained its value across centuries, cultures and civilisations. It serves as a reliable store of wealth, especially during economic uncertainties.
Historical Significance: Throughout the millennia, gold has been used as a currency and symbolises wealth. Gold carries a historical and cultural appeal that enhances its investment allure.

Drawbacks

Storage Costs: Storing physical gold securely can be expensive. Investors need to consider the cost of storage solutions such as safes or vaults, and possibly insurance protection.
Security Concerns: The tangible nature of physical gold made it susceptible to theft, necessitating enhanced security measures that add to the overall cost of investment.
Limited Liquidity: Selling physical gold, especially jewellery, can be time-consuming and complex compared to digital or paper gold. The resale value might not always match the prevailing gold market price due to factors like design, craftmanship and wear and tear.

Digital Gold: A Virtual Approach to Gold Investment

Digital gold offers investors the convenience to trade the asset online, eliminating the complexity associated with physical gold storage and transportation. Online trading platforms have made gold investment more accessible to a broader audience.

Digital Gold Trading Platforms

Digital gold platforms offer a convenient way to invest in gold without physical complexities. By purchasing a specific amount of gold through these online platforms, investors can own a portion of this precious metal securely stored in digital form.

For Malaysian investors, Bursa Gold Dinar offers a local alternative, providing a platform to invest in high-purity gold with the convenience of digital transactions.

Benefits

Convenience: Digital gold platforms make it quick and straightforward to buy and sell gold, allowing users to complete a transaction with just a few clicks. Platforms like Bursa Gold Dinar provides a user-friendly interface for easy gold trading. Similarly, TNG eWallet's e-Mas feature enables users to invest in digital gold conveniently through their mobile devices. Additionally, Bank Muamalat's EasiGold platform allows customers to purchase and manage gold investments digitally, offering features like live pricing and secure storage.
Allowed for Small Investments: Investors can buy gold in small denominations. On some platforms, investors can trade digital golds from as low as MYR 10.00, making it accessible to everyone.
Low Storage Costs: Since the gold is stored securely by the platform, investors do not need to worry about the costs and logistics of storing physical gold. Platforms like DigiGold and The Royal Mint ensure that the gold is kept in secure vaults. They are also fully insured and regularly audited.

Drawbacks

Platform Dependency: The reliability of digital gold platform is crucial. While most platforms are reputable, there is always a risk of instability or security breaches. Thorough research to determine platform's credibility is crucial before investing.
Cybersecurity concerns: As with any online transactions, digital gold investments are susceptible to fraud and hacking. While platforms implement security measures, risk of cybersecurity breaches cannot be eliminated. Investors should prioritise using trusted platforms with strong security protocols.

Gold Derivatives: Futures Contracts, Options, and Other Derivatives

Gold derivatives, such as futures contracts and options, allow investors the opportunity to speculate on the future price of gold without owning the physical metal. These financial instruments derive their value from gold as the underlying asset.

Benefits

Leverage: Gold derivatives offer investors the opportunity to control a larger position with a relatively small amount of capital
High Profit Potential: The leverage provided by gold derivatives means that even small changes in the price of gold can result in significant percentage gains. This potential for high returns makes gold derivatives attractive to investors looking to maximise profit from small price fluctuations.
Hedging: Gold derivatives serve as effective tools for managing risk against portfolio volatility. Investors who hold physical gold or gold-related assets can use futures and options to protect their portfolios from adverse price movements.

Drawbacks

High Risk: The reliability of digital gold platform is crucial. While most platforms are reputable, there is always a risk of instability or security breaches. Thorough research to determine platform's credibility is crucial before investing.
Complexity: Gold derivatives are intricate financial instruments, necessitating a deep understanding of complex terms like strike price, expiration date, and implied volatility. This complexity can be a barrier for novice investors, increasing the likelihood of errors and losses.
Potential for Substantial Losses: Given the high-risk nature of the derivatives, investors can incur substantial losses. Options, for instance, can expire worthless, resulting in a total loss of the premium paid if the market moves in contrary to the investor’s expectations.

Investing in Gold Publicly Listed Companies (PLCs)

Investing in public-listed companies involved in gold mining and production provides indirect exposure to gold prices. These companies engage in the extraction and refinement of gold, and their stock performance is often linked to the price of gold.

Benefits

Exposure to Gold Industry Growth: By investing in gold mining and production companies, investors can benefit from the growth and profitability of the gold industry. Gold price rises often result in increased revenues and profits for these companies, which can drive stock price appreciation.
Dividend Income: Some gold mining companies pay dividends to their shareholders. This can provide a steady income stream in addition to potential capital gains. Dividends can be particularly attractive during periods of stable or rising gold prices.
Potential for Capital Appreciation: Shares in gold mining companies can appreciate significantly, especially when gold prices are on an upward trend. This potential for capital gains can make these stocks attractive to growth-oriented investors.

Drawbacks

Company-Specific Risks: The performance of gold mining companies is tied to corporate performance such as operational efficiency, management decisions, and other company-specific factors, beyond market volatility. Issues such as poor management, operational mishaps, or regulatory challenges can negatively impact a company's stock price, regardless of the overall trend in gold market.
Market Volatility: Stocks of gold mining companies can be more volatile than the price of gold itself. Broader market trends, investor sentiment, and sector-specific news can cause significant price fluctuation. This volatility makes stocks riskier than some other investments.
Indirect Exposure to Gold Prices: While gold prices influence gold mining stocks, they also depend on the companies' production costs, reserve levels, and other operational factors. As a result, their stock prices may not always move in direct correlation with gold prices. Investors seeking a pure play on gold prices might prefer direct investments in gold (in physical or digital forms) or gold ETFs.

Gold Funds (ETFs and Mutual Funds)

Gold-focused ETFs(Exchange-Traded Funds) and mutual funds offers investors a diversified approach to investing in gold without the need to own physical gold. These funds invest in various gold-related assets, offering a convenient avenue to gain exposure to gold's price movements.

Benefits

Diversification: Gold ETFs and mutual funds spread risk across multiple assets. By holding a portfolio of gold-related securities, these funds can help mitigate the impact of volatility in individual stocks or gold prices.
Professional Management: Mutual funds are managed by professional fund managers who make investment decisions about the trading of the gold-related assets. Their expertise can enhance returns and provide a more stable investment compared to direct ownership of gold.
Liquidity: Gold ETFs, like individual stocks, are traded on stock exchanges, allowing for easy buying and selling. This high liquidity ensures that investors can quickly enter or exit positions, making gold ETFs a flexible investment option.

Drawbacks

Management Fees: Both ETFs and mutual funds incur management fees. While ETFs generally have lower expense ratios compared to actively managed mutual funds, these costs can still impact overall returns. It's important to consider these fees when evaluating potential investments.
Potential Underperformance: Gold mutual funds, which primarily invest in gold mining companies, might not always match the performance of physical gold. These funds' performance can be affected by the operational and financial health of the underlying mining companies, which introduces additional risk factors.

The Golden Hour

Investing in gold offers diverse options, each with unique sets of advantages and challenges. Physical gold gives tangible ownership but requires secure storage. Digital gold provides convenience, while gold derivatives amplify returns but also magnify risks. Investing in gold mining companies can provide dividends and capital gains but returns are often tied to the company’s operations. Gold ETFs and mutual funds offer diversification and professional management, though they might not always match physical gold's performance.

Ultimately, the best gold investment strategies depend on your financial goals, risk tolerance and investment horizon. Diversification across different gold investment options and staying informed of the market news can help manage risk. Learn more at Bursa Academy to deepen your understanding and make informed decisions.

Doris Liew is an economist, public policy thinker and writer who regularly observes ASEAN’s economic development, regional and international trade, developmental issues, labour economics, poverty and inequality, and political economy.